- A multi year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) is the simplest annuity product: pay a lump sum, lock a fixed interest rate for a stated term.
- MYGAs typically offer rates 50-150 basis points higher than CDs of comparable duration, plus tax-deferred growth on interest earnings.
- Common terms: 3, 5, 7, 10 years. 10% annual penalty free withdrawal allowance during the term. Surrender charges beyond that.
- Best fit: buyers seeking better-than-CD returns with similar simplicity, in the conservative bucket of a retirement portfolio.
Multi year guaranteed annuities, often called MYGAs, are the simplest annuity products on the market and one of the fastest-growing categories of insurance sales in the current rate environment. This MYGA explained guide covers what they are, how they work, how they compare to bank certificates of deposit, and the situations where they make the most sense.
What is a multi year guaranteed annuity?
A multi year guaranteed annuity is a type of fixed annuity issued by a life insurance company. You pay a single lump sum premium, and the issuing insurance company guarantees a fixed interest rate for a stated number of years. At the end of the guarantee period, you can withdraw the full account value, renew the contract at a new rate, or roll the proceeds into a new annuity through a tax-free 1035 exchange.
That is essentially the entire product. There are no caps, no participation rates, no income riders, no market exposure. The guaranteed interest rate is contractually defined for the entire term. For buyers who want CD-like simplicity with annuity tax treatment and often a higher rate, MYGAs are the cleanest option in the annuity market.
How MYGAs work
When you purchase a multi year guaranteed annuity, you commit your premium for the chosen term length. Common terms are 3, 5, 7, and 10 years. Longer terms typically pay higher rates, though the relationship can flatten or invert during certain rate environments.
Throughout the term, the contract earns a fixed interest rate guaranteed by the issuing insurance company. Interest earnings grow tax deferred, meaning you do not pay income tax on the gains each year as you would in a taxable account. The tax bill comes when you eventually withdraw the money or annuitize the contract.
Most MYGAs include limited penalty free withdrawals during the term, typically up to 10 percent of the contract value annually. Withdrawals beyond that trigger surrender charges. Withdrawals before age 59½ may also incur a 10 percent IRS penalty on the gains portion.
At the end of the guarantee period, you typically have a 30-day window to withdraw the funds without penalty, or you can let the contract renew at the new rate the carrier offers. The renewal rate is rarely as attractive as the original purchase rate, so most buyers use the maturity window to either cash out or 1035 exchange into a new MYGA at a competitive rate.
MYGAs vs certificates of deposit (CDs)
This is the comparison most buyers actually care about. Certificates of deposit CDs and MYGAs both offer a guaranteed interest rate for a fixed term. The differences matter:
Rates. MYGA rates are typically higher than CD rates of comparable duration, often by 50 to 150 basis points. Life insurers invest premium dollars in longer-duration assets than banks do, which lets them offer higher rates on long-term commitments.
Tax treatment. CDs generate taxable interest income each year, which you pay tax on annually. MYGAs grow tax deferred, so the full balance compounds without annual taxation. For high earners or buyers in their peak earning years, this difference compounds meaningfully over the term.
Insurance versus banking. CDs are issued by banks and backed by FDIC insurance up to $250,000 per depositor per institution. MYGAs are issued by life insurance companies and backed by the company's claims-paying ability and the state guaranty associations that protect annuity contracts up to state-specific limits (typically $250,000 to $500,000).
Liquidity. CDs generally allow you to break the contract by paying an interest penalty. MYGAs have surrender charge schedules that can be more restrictive, though the 10 percent annual penalty free withdrawal feature provides reasonable flexibility.
For buyers comfortable with the insurance company guarantee structure, MYGAs typically deliver better after-tax outcomes than CDs over multi-year terms.
MYGAs vs traditional fixed annuities
A MYGA is technically a type of fixed annuity, but the term "traditional fixed annuities" is often used for annuities with a one-year guarantee period that resets annually based on the carrier's declared rate. Traditional fixed annuities offer less rate certainty since the renewal rate can drop significantly after year one.
MYGAs solve this problem by locking in the rate for the full term. For buyers who want long term growth with no surprises, the MYGA structure is generally superior.
MYGAs and stock market alternatives
A MYGA is not designed to compete with the stock market. The stock market historically offers higher long term growth potential, but with full downside risk. A MYGA offers a guaranteed return with zero market exposure, though it does not provide a guaranteed income stream like an immediate annuity. The right comparison is not MYGA versus stocks, but MYGA versus bonds, CDs, or other low-risk fixed income products.
For retirement savings allocated to the conservative bucket of a portfolio, MYGAs often outperform comparable bonds and CDs while offering similar safety. They are not a replacement for equity allocation in a balanced retirement plan.
Who issues MYGAs
The MYGA market includes both large mainstream carriers and smaller life insurers that specialize in the category. American National, Athene, MassMutual Ascend, Sentinel Security Life, Oceanview, and Atlantic Coast Life are all active MYGA issuers. Rates vary day to day based on each carrier's investment yield and capacity needs.
Smaller, lower-rated carriers sometimes offer higher rates to attract premium, which creates the trade-off of higher rate versus higher counterparty risk. For premium amounts within the state guaranty association coverage limit, the additional risk may be acceptable. For larger amounts, sticking with A-rated carriers is the conservative choice.
Pros and cons of MYGAs
Pros:
- Simple, transparent product structure
- Higher rates than comparable CDs in most environments
- Tax deferred growth on the interest earnings
- No market risk, no caps, no participation rates to track
- Multiple term options (3, 5, 7, 10 year guaranteed annuities MYGA)
Cons:
- Surrender charges limit early access beyond the 10 percent annual allowance
- Renewal rates rarely match purchase rates
- Less liquid than CDs and money market accounts
- Tax on withdrawals is at ordinary income rates, not capital gains
- Not protected by FDIC; relies on state guaranty associations and the issuing carrier's strength
Who a MYGA fits best
A MYGA is a strong fit for buyers seeking better-than-CD returns with similar simplicity, retirees building a fixed-income ladder in a tax-deferred wrapper, high earners who want to shelter interest earnings from current taxation, and conservative savers who do not need active income from the funds during the term.
It is a poor fit for buyers who need full liquidity, those who want market upside, or buyers under age 59½ who may need access to funds before the IRS penalty window closes.
Frequently asked questions
Are MYGAs safe? MYGAs are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company, plus state guaranty association coverage up to state-specific limits. For an A-rated carrier, the practical risk of nonpayment is very low.
Can I lose money in a MYGA? Not from interest crediting, since the rate is contractually guaranteed. You can lose principal value if you surrender the contract during the surrender charge period and the charge exceeds the gains you earned.
Are MYGA rates fixed for the entire term? Yes. The headline interest rate is guaranteed for the entire chosen term. Renewal rates after the term ends are not guaranteed in advance.
The bottom line
The multi year guaranteed annuity is the simplest annuity product available and often the best fit for buyers who want CD-like predictability with better rates and tax treatment. If you are comparing a MYGA against a CD or a short-term bond ladder, the math typically favors the MYGA over multi-year periods, provided you do not need access to the funds before maturity.
Considering a MYGA over a bank CD?
Rates change weekly across carriers. Get an independent rate comparison for your specific term length and premium amount, with no sales pressure.
Book a Free Review →